"I think the paper is techincally sound, but I think that it is quite narrow in
scope, and am not sure it will be of great general interest. There are only few
and unsurprising conclusions, and moreover the results seem to indicate that
there is an interacation between IN/OUT and the specific FS algorithms used.
Focussing so strongly on toy data, is also a considerable worry. I recommend
rejection. "
It seems that this year is not my "lucky" year. This is the same situation for my intern applications. Getting so many interviews(7 interviews), but none of them makes an offer.
Anyway, just keep going!
Defending Theory
-
In the June CACM, Micah Beck writes an opinion piece Accept the Consequences where
he is quite skeptical of the role of theory in real-world software
dev...